Home/Comparisons/Excel & spreadsheets
Comparison · Excel & spreadsheets

Excel vs Alstre.
It's not about the table — it's about what happens while you serve the customer.

A spreadsheet is the most common “system” in a window and door showroom, and there's no shame in that — for a dozen or so jobs a month run by one person, it does the job. The trouble starts when a job passes through the surveyor, the sales adviser, the installation crew and service — because then what counts isn't the table, but who saw what, when, and on what basis.

The answer in two steps
A

Stay with the spreadsheet if

  • you run the business alone or with one other person and do the measuring yourself
  • you sell without installation, so you don't plan crews or handovers
  • your customers are almost all businesses and complaints are rare
  • there are so few jobs that you remember each one by name
B

Switch to a system if

  • someone other than the person writing the quote does the measuring
  • you install at customers' homes and plan crews' work
  • you sell to consumers, and complaints need a reply on time
  • an employee leaves and the question is what they take with them
Try it free
Coverage

What each tool covers

Both tools accompany the same process, but on different stretches of it. Below you can see where each one actually works and where its scope ends.

Order stage
  1. Contact
  2. Measure
  3. Quote
  4. Contract
  5. Install
  6. Service
Excel & spreadsheets
Alstre
coveredpartly, by handout of scope

A spreadsheet accompanies almost the whole journey of a job, but everywhere in the same way: it records what someone types in and enforces nothing. Two stretches drop out entirely — the document for the customer is made in a word processor, and the service history from years ago has nowhere to live, because the file from that year was overwritten long ago.

Differences

Point-by-point comparison

Each row is one feature you can check in both tools, regardless of who is describing it.

Change history

Excel & spreadsheetsWho changed the price in a cell and when — usually impossible to tell. The previous version of the file lives in a copy with a date in its name.

AlstreEvery change records the author, the operation, the date, the IP address and the location. The log is searchable and can be exported.

Access to data

Excel & spreadsheetsThe file is all or nothing: whoever has access has the whole customer database. A copy on a USB stick leaves no trace.

AlstreFive roles and three levels of data visibility. A sales adviser can see only their own customers; deactivating an account keeps the history but cuts off access.

On-site measurement

Excel & spreadsheetsA paper sheet or a note on the phone, retyped in the evening. Photos stay in the surveyor's gallery.

AlstreA measurement wizard on the phone, fourteen product categories, photos and the customer's signature on screen. Works without signal and syncs later.

Customer documents

Excel & spreadsheetsQuote and contract assembled in a word processor, usually by copying the previous one. That's how other people's names end up in contracts.

AlstreThe PDF quote is created from the measurement, the contract from the accepted quote. B2C and B2B clauses switch according to the buyer's status.

Complaint deadlines

Excel & spreadsheetsYou have to remember yourself when a complaint needs a reply. A spreadsheet won't remind you.

AlstreA 14-day first-reply deadline runs in the ticket and is visible on the list. The complaint is linked to the contract, measurement and installation, so you can see what it concerns.

Several people at once

Excel & spreadsheetsA shared file works until someone works offline and makes a copy “just in case”. Then there are two versions of the truth.

AlstreOne database. A change made by the adviser is visible to the installation crew at once, without sending a file.

Personal data protection

Excel & spreadsheetsA file with customers' home addresses, phone numbers and passport details circulates in attachments. Showing who had access to it is practically impossible.

AlstreRole-based access, an event log and operation history — the material you need to demonstrate the accountability that data protection laws such as the GDPR require.

Gaps

Limitations that show up in practice

Each of them only makes itself felt at a complaint, an inspection or when an employee leaves — that is, when there's no time left to catch up. Next to each, we point to the feature that covers it.

A complaint three years later

A customer reports a defect and asks about the parameters from the measurement. With a spreadsheet you have to find the file from that year and hope nobody overwrote it. In the system you click the contract number and have the measurement, photos, installer and history.

Complaints and service

An employee leaving

A sales adviser with full access to the file walks out with the whole contact database. Roles and visibility levels limit how much anyone can take, and the event log shows what they downloaded.

Roles and permissions

The VAT rate on every item

In a spreadsheet the rate is whatever someone typed into that cell — and a wrong one surfaces only when the customer's accountant checks the invoice. In the system you set your company's VAT rates once, and every quote item picks from them.

Quotes

Two crews, one week

Moving an installation in a spreadsheet means notifying everyone separately. A calendar split by crew shows the change at once, together with multi-stage installations and subcontractors.

Installation calendar

Document numbering

Manual contract numbers work until there are two branches or two people issuing at the same moment. Then duplicates appear that you have to explain to your accountant.

Numbering

How do you know what you earn

Conversion from measurement to contract needs a separate table in a spreadsheet that someone has to maintain. They usually stop after two months.

Statistics
Switching

How the switch goes

Four stages, including one you can't skip: working in both tools in parallel for the first week.

  1. Step 1

    Import the customer database

    We upload the contacts from your spreadsheet during onboarding. It's the only stage where data has to be moved in bulk.

  2. Step 2

    One trial job

    You run your next measurement in both places in parallel. After the quote you can see whether the system actually shortens the road.

  3. Step 3

    Your own templates

    Your contract and warranty go into the template editor, so documents look the way they always have — only now they create themselves.

  4. Step 4

    The spreadsheet stays read-only

    Old jobs usually don't need migrating. The file stays as an archive, and new jobs go through the system only.

Questions

Frequently asked questions

Can I import data from Excel?
Yes. We import the customer database during onboarding from the file you already have. Historical quotes and contracts usually aren't moved — the spreadsheet stays as a read-only archive, and new jobs go through the system.
Isn't Excel simply cheaper?
On the licence alone, yes. The difference lies elsewhere: in the time spent retyping measurements, in quotes sent the next day instead of the same afternoon, and in the cost of one complaint that can't be reconstructed. That's why we suggest comparing on one real job, not on the price list.
I run the business alone. Does this make sense for me?
Often not — and we say so plainly. If you measure, quote and install yourself, a spreadsheet can be enough. The system starts paying off when a job passes through several people, or when you sell to consumers and complaints need a reply on time.
Will I lose the flexibility of a spreadsheet?
Partly, yes, and that's a real cost of switching. In return you get things a spreadsheet can't do without a programmer: change history with the author, access limits for each person, on-site measurement without signal, and documents built from data rather than by copying the previous file.
Decision

Test it on a real job of your own

Fourteen days, no payment card. Enter your next measurement and see where the road to a contract gets shorter — and where nothing changes.